Log In
  • Android and Me
  • News
  • Apps
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • Deals
  • Threads
Trending Tags: Nexus 4 Reviews Samsung HTC Motorola Verizon T-Mobile Rumors SummerRSS Feed Android and Me on Twitter Android and Me on Google+ Android and Me on Facebook Android and Me on YouTube Android and Me on Klout

Android and Me

  • 6 days ago

    Android 4.3 and white Nexus 4 coming June 10

    #Android 4.3 #Nexus
  • 7 days ago

    Google reveals Samsung Galaxy S 4 Nexus Edition

    #Samsung #Nexus
  • 7 days ago

    Android passes 900 million devices activated

    #Android #Google
    video
  • 28 days ago

    Best no-contract plans for unlocked Android devices

    #no-contract #unlocked
News
Nov 17 AT 10:28 AM Anthony Domanico 17 Comments

Opinion: Should Google+ have a separate Music section?

Tweet


google-plus-music-sharing

Now that the endorphins have worn off and we’ve had a little time to digest Google’s Music Store launch, we can begin to tackle both the good and the bad that result from Google’s Music Service.

One of the most acclaimed additions to the service was the tight integration with Google+. Users can purchase songs on the Google Music Store and share their purchases with people in their circles, who in turn receive 1 free listen to the full song you purchased.

While being able to see and hear what your friends and acquaintances are purchasing on Google Music is an awesome addition to the Music service, the tight Google+ integration potentially has at least one significant drawback. If Google’s Music Store takes off, streams are going to be more cluttered. For every person out there who enjoys sharing and receiving shared music, another one doesn’t, and Music shares are automatically shared to the main feed for all who’ve circled you to see.

Google can easily remedy this potential issue by integrating Music similarly to how they integrated Games. Games has its own separate tab on the Google+ home screen, and Games notifications are buried within the Games tab, leaving your main stream clutter free (unless you count the hundreds of animated gifs floating around out there).

This solution would let users who are interested in seeing what others are listening to the ability to quickly and easily find music posts, and would keep streams clean for users who don’t really care about shared music.

We’re aware that launch day is not an accurate projection for how this service will be used in the future after the excitement has died down, but we also recognize that Music sharing has the potential to be big. With over 200 million Android devices out there, and Google heavily pushing their Google+ social networking service into all aspects of their business, we are not likely to see Google+ music sharing fizzle out anytime soon.

What do you guys think? Is building out a separate Music section in Google+ a good idea, or are we making much ado about nothing?

Anthony loves all things technology, from hardware to apps and games. You can connect with him via Google+ or Twitter by clicking one of the fancy doo-dads above.
  • Tagged
  • #android market
  • #android music market
  • #google
  • #google music
  • #google music store
  • #music sharing
  • #Opinion

    Most Tweeted This Week

  • White Nexus 4 and Android 4.3 coming June 10th

    white-nexus-4-630
  • Updated: HTC employee teases Google Experience HTC One

    stock-android-htc-one
  • Google updating Android without updating Android is the biggest news out of I/O 2013

    android-magazine-spread

17 Comments Join the discussion!

Sort by DateRating
  1. 69GeauxLSU 11/17/11 10:35 AM
    Thumb upThumb down +9

    I would say this is a no brainer. Not only might the main feed get cluttered, there’s also the out of sight out of mind part of it. What I mean by that is if I’m at work and see a song on a main feed, I probably won’t listen to it. I’ll probably forget about it by the time I get home. But if there is a seperate tab for music, I may get into the habbit of checking the music tab when I get home and have time to listen to new stuff.

    Reply
    • 76Jes 11/17/11 10:51 AM
      Thumb upThumb down 0

      You know, I was going to go with the latter (much ado about nothing) but you bring up a good point. I’m a music junkie and although I would not mind being bombarded with new music posts, I would probably forget to look up those suggestions later when I got the time unless there was a dedicated Music section to corral all the shares.

      So yes, I do think there should be a dedicated section for music, but at the same time I think we should still be allowed to share suggestions to our streams.

      Reply
      • 65Javier Bastardo 11/17/11 10:57 AM
        Thumb upThumb down 0

        Maybe they could implement a way so you could Search for only posts with the Google Music widget on it on the “Search Google+” box. It could simple, no need to create a whole section many won’t mind not having, and the search will give you a nice list I guess.

        Reply
    • AppleFUDGuest 11/17/11 11:06 AM
      Thumb upThumb down +1

      You make a good point. I would be more likely to check a music tab/circle and run through all recently purchased shared music to see what my “friends” think is worth buying. . . but in a main feed, yeah that’ll get lost quickly.

      Reply
  2. 65Javier Bastardo 11/17/11 10:41 AM
    Thumb upThumb down +1

    Not all people are into buying music, or share them, even more since the service is only U.S. available. Just like it is show in one of the videos you could create an “Audiophile” circle and just share with them, people who are deeply into music wont mind having their stream filled with new or undiscovered songs, I imagine.

    But, I must say the idea of a whole new tab just for music isn’t all that bad. Maybe it could have an option so you can set if the Music notifications appear or not on the regular Stream, and instead of having Featured Games it could have Featured Bands.

    Me personally, I’m not worried of having my G+ clustered with songs, just as I do not worry about animated gifs, of which I see only a couple per day. G+ is really about personal experience, not really the same for all users.

    Reply
    • RichGuest 11/17/11 12:13 PM
      Thumb upThumb down +3

      Yeah, I think that regardless of if they add a Music tab (like they have for Games) I definitely think they should give users the option disabling music shares in your main G+ stream! Google need to make sure that for every new feature they add (and you can be sure that there are many more to come!) there is an option to make said feature hidden to you

      Reply
      • 99Anthony Domanico 11/17/11 1:05 PM
        Thumb upThumb down 0

        Especially for such a big feature as Music.

        Reply
        • 65Javier Bastardo 11/21/11 9:15 PM
          Thumb upThumb down 0

          After the initial period I’m no longer seeing Music posts on my Stream, ‘cept a very few and disperse ones from people that works at Google. This doesn’t proof anything about Music itself, but I think the fact that it is only for U.S. residents really has an effect on this.

          Reply
  3. 96pekosROB 11/17/11 10:50 AM
    Thumb upThumb down +2

    So being a member here shows I’m an obvious Google/Android fan. What I don’t get is that almost everyone in the industry is happy and glad to see yet another competitor in the digital music industry.

    But yesterday I read the one review that totally trashed Google Music, and that was by Adrian Covert at Gizmodo. He really had nothing nice to say, and even downplayed the 20,000 free songs uploaded as well, since you have to “upload” them. I don’t get how anyone can say 20,000 songs (that you can use as a back up and access virtually anywhere) without paying a monthly or yearly fee is no big deal. He is a total moron and a fool.

    I’m not excited about getting music through Google, but at least I get another option from iTunes and Amazon. Hell, I haven’t bought a song from iTunes in at least 2 years. I still prefer CDs. Yes, I’m old school in that way.

    Sorry, had to rant about stupid iPhone loving douchebags. Google Music for its 20,000 song upload for free to the cloud is worth it alone, the rest is just icing on the cake in my opinion.

    Reply
    • 96pekosROB 11/17/11 10:52 AM
      Thumb upThumb down +1

      Oh yeah, and might as well have tighter G+ integration, it would help the activity increase on G+ and sharing songs with your friends sounds like something that should be going on in a social network like G+.

      Reply
      • 44Droid Dewd 11/17/11 4:41 PM
        Thumb upThumb down 0

        Yeah I had to check out that Gizmodo article –if you could call it that more like a long winded rant. I can’t say he’s a Apple fanboy but he sure has a beef against Google. Looks more like an opinion piece than a real article to me.

        Reply
  4. jGuest 11/17/11 12:16 PM
    Thumb upThumb down -1

    i couldn’t care less for music sharing.
    i’d definately consider it spam if i see it in the main stream.
    it needs its own section or just to go away.

    Reply
  5. android free appsGuest 11/17/11 2:49 PM
    Thumb upThumb down 0

    we’ll see what happens

    Reply
  6. 100Nick Gray 11/17/11 3:27 PM
    Thumb upThumb down 0

    I’m sure Google will be tweaking things once it’s been out for a while. Those of us who use G+ know how quickly they change or add features. Google will be watching things closely to see how Google Music shares impact people feeds. The last thing they want right now is to have people quit on G+ because of Google Music.

    I think their approach for now is to integrate the shares in order to get more people to use Google Music and build a solid customer base.

    Reply
  7. 13mshramek 11/17/11 4:21 PM
    Thumb upThumb down 0

    I definitely think so. That would make it very easy to find the music your friends are listening to without cluttering up the feed with a bunch of songs.

    Reply
  8. thaJackGuest 11/27/11 7:42 PM
    Thumb upThumb down 0

    Agreed. I also believe that posting an animated GIF should be punishable by death.

    Reply
  9. 42pritams 12/18/11 4:11 AM
    Thumb upThumb down 0

    yeah…

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Hotly debated

white-nexus-4-630

Android 4.3 and white Nexus 4 coming June 10

89
sgs4-nexus-630

Google reveals Samsung Galaxy S 4 Nexus Edition

69
Screen Shot 2013-05-16 at 12.50.39 PM

Copy boosts free storage capacity to 15GB to fight Google’s new shared storage

66
stock-android-htc-one

Updated: HTC employee teases Google Experience HTC One

49
android-magazine-spread

Google updating Android without updating Android is the biggest news out of I/O 2013

44

Top Links

  • 0 HTC in disarray: staff departures, ‘disastrous’ First, and production problems cloud company’s futuretheverge.com
  • 0 New Ways to Optimize Your Business in Google Playandroid-developers.blogspot.com
  • 0 A stretched Samsung chases rival Apple’s suppliersreuters.com
  • 0 One-third of all smartphone sales were prepaid in Q1m.cnet.com

Top commenters

  • Nick Gray Thumb up Thumb down +22

    on HTC J One heads to Japan with microSD card support

  • phor11 Thumb up Thumb down +9

    on Hangouts is the the future of Google Voice, desktop calling will be back

  • squiddy20 Thumb up Thumb down +9

    on White Nexus 4 and Android 4.3 coming June 10th

Threads

  • Fairphone: Anyone heard of it? 1 SGB101 2 hours ago
  • HTC One + Samsung GS4= Innovation? 4 jerrbomb 48 mins ago
  • AT&T HTC One X on T-Mobile?? 2 jamal adam 1 day ago

Staff

  • © 2013 Android and Me
SAY Channel Tech
Login

Register | Lost your password?

Register

A password will be e-mailed to you.

Log in | Lost your password?

Reset Password

Log in| Register

Powered by SimpleModal Login